BIBLE HISTORY DAILY

The Golden Calf

Made by Man...or God?

Golden Calf

Photo by David Harris/Collection Israel Museum

Aaron instructed the people to rip off their gold earrings, which, the text tells us explicitly and unambiguously, “he made into a molten calf” (Exodus 32:4)—the famous Golden Calf. “These,” the people responded, “are your gods, O Israel, who brought you out of the land of Egypt!”

When Moses came down from the mountain and saw the Golden Calf, he became enraged and hurled the two tablets to the ground, smashing them to smithereens. And he burned the Golden Calf until it became a powder that he mixed with water, and then he made the wayward Israelites drink the resulting potion (Exodus 32:20), thereby calling attention to their infidelity (see Numbers 5:11–31).

Then he asked Aaron for an explanation. Why did he do it? Aaron replied, “Let my lord not be enraged … They said to me, ‘Make us a god to lead us; for that man Moses, who brought us from the land of Egypt—we do not know what happened to him.’ So I said to them, ‘Whoever has gold, rip it off.’ They gave it to me and I hurled it into the fire and out came this calf!” (Exodus 32:24).


FREE ebook: Ancient Israel in Egypt and the Exodus.

* Indicates a required field.

Aaron’s response to Moses seems an outright lie. In the earlier telling (Exodus 32:4), the biblical narrator reported that Aaron had “made” the gold into a molten calf; he didn’t hurl it into the fire, only to see it magically transformed into a calf.

Not only is Aaron telling an outright lie, but the incredible event he claims occurred is also quite incomprehensible.

Golden Calf

National Gallery, London, UK/Bridgeman Art Library

Some traditional Jewish exegetes, unhappy with Aaron seeming to be a liar, give credence to his response to Moses. For example, the great 11th-century commentator known as Rashi (short for Rabbi Solomon son of Isaac, of Troyes) tells us that Aaron’s explanation meant, “I didn’t know that this calf would come forth, but it came forth!” In other words, Aaron had nothing to do with it; he is exonerated. Rashi is here echoing various midrashima and legends which claimed that the calf was the work of the devil and that it did in fact come forth from the fire spontaneously.

One later legend even has it that the calf came forth alive.  Another legend asserts that the calf came forth by itself, empowered by residual magic from an amulet that Moses himself had made to raise Joseph’s sunken coffin from the Nile, but had then left unused.

I believe the key to understanding Aaron’s claim lies in understanding certain Mesopotamian texts concerning the idols as gods.



Become a Member of Biblical Archaeology Society Now and Get More Than Half Off the Regular Price of the All-Access Pass!

Explore the world’s most intriguing Biblical scholarship

Dig into more than 9,000 articles in the Biblical Archaeology Society’s vast library plus much more with an All-Access pass.

access

When a divine statue was sculpted in Mesopotamia, a so-called mouth-washing ritual was performed before the statue became the corporeal manifestation of the god itself—a living, anthropomorphic cult statue. The ritual assimilated the finite, physical image to the transcendent, intangible god, transforming the humanly manufactured icon into a living deity. Details about the mouth-washing ritual have already been described to BR readers.b Briefly, the mouth-washing ritual was a two-day event during which the cult statue was led by the incantation priest from the workshop where it was produced to a specially erected reed hut in an orchard by the riverbank; there it was ritually purified, enlivened and activated as a god. It was then escorted to its temple, where it was installed and honored as a living god. The actual washing of its mouth was believed to enliven the statue.

Golden Calf

Private Collection/Bridgeman Art Library

Cuneiform tablets contain different versions of the ritual, and scholars have explained it in different ways. Some see it as a kind of birthing process.3 Others see it as a kind of rite of passage. But in the different explanations and the different versions of the ritual and of the accompanying incantations, there is a common denominator: the idea that the divine statue is in fact a god created by gods and not by humans.

Numerous incantational pronouncements and rituals provide ideas about how the inert statue was thought to have become a god. Some pronouncements describe an autogenetic birth (a self-creation) in heaven. In others, the crafts-god Ea is said to be the statue’s father. On occasion, the wood from which the statue was made is said to have come from a holy forest. Sometimes the statue is said to have been manufactured by gods. A ritual instruction describes a ceremony in which the hands of the artisan who fashioned the statue are ritually cut off, as if to declare him not to be the sculptor. Finally, some tablets specifically deny the role of human artisans in the fabrication process.

Thus, although the gods are born both in myth and in ritual, they seem to have created themselves. According to a Sumerian version, the statue is born in heaven and made on earth of itself—somewhat like Aaron’s explanation of the autogenesis of the Golden Calf. In another text, Sennacherib, king of Assyria, states that Anshar “made the statue of Anshar, king of all the great gods, creator of himself.” The manufacturing of the statue by the king and the skilled artisans is in fact a rehearsal for the mythological moment when Anshar creates himself.

It is as if the Mesopotamian idol makers were answering “no” to Jeremiah’s rhetorical question, “Can a man make gods for himself? No gods are they” (Jeremiah 16:20). The idol makers, too, recognized the impossibility of a man creating a god. However, rather than desisting from the attempt, the Mesopotamian idol makers claimed that they were not actually making a god, but the gods themselves were.

In the Golden Calf episode, first the narrator tells us what really happened, then Aaron tells Moses his very different version. Aaron, perhaps inspired by a Mesopotamian-like belief in the autogenesis of the divine statues, is invoking this as an exculpatory explanation to his brother: “I, Aaron, didn’t make the statue; it made itself.”


FREE ebook: Ancient Israel in Egypt and the Exodus.

* Indicates a required field.

But perhaps there is something deeper. The narrator, by recounting first what really happened and then what Aaron says occurred, is signaling to the reader the spuriousness of the belief in autogenesis of divine statues. The narrator is really saying, “C’mon, Aaron, don’t be ridiculous; golden calves don’t just jump out of the fire.”

This may reflect conditions in the seventh century B.C.E., when, some scholars say, this text was actually written. The northern kingdom of Israel had broken away and set up golden calves in their temples in Dan and Bethel to compete with the Jerusalem Temple in Judah. Perhaps the explanation Aaron gives to Moses was a mocking of claims the priests of the temples of Dan and Bethel may have made that their golden calves were divinely fabricated. The priests’ claims would have been as baseless as Aaron’s far-fetched explanation of how the Golden Calf happened to have been at the foot of the mountain to greet Moses on his return.

———
Victor Hurowitz (d. 2013) was a former Professor of Bible, Archaeology and Ancient Near Eastern studies at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev in Israel. He published widely on Assyriology and Mesopotamian religion, including the book I Have Built You an Exalted House (Sheffield, 1992) and Proverbs: Introduction and Commentary (The Magnes Press, 2012). He was on the editorial boards of Olam Ha- Tanakh, Mo‘ed, Bet Mikra and Shnaton: Annual for the Study of the Bible and the Ancient Near East. In 2012 he was selected as Israel’s representative of the International Association of Assyriology.


This article originally appeared in Bible Review in 2004.

Related Posts

Apr 20
Who Was Thecla?

By: Megan Sauter

The Horbat-Raqiq ivory jar from 6,000 years ago, reconstructed. Dafna Gazit, Israel Antiquities Authority
Apr 19
Prehistoric Ivory Jar Found Near Be’er Sheva

By: Biblical Archaeology Society Staff

georg-grosz-cain
Apr 18
Cain and Abel in the Bible

By: Elie Wiesel


1 Responses

  1. Mahlon Marr says:

    The story of the Golden Calf in Exodus doesn’t make sense. The Israelites, who had just 2 months before been delivered from the Egyptians by the extraordinary supernatural events performed by God in the pillar of cloud and fire, were then worshipping a golden calf in the very presence of God in that pillar. Then centuries later, following the death of Solomon, Jeroboam broke Israel away from the united monarchy and set up two temples with golden calf idols in Bethel and Dan to be in competition with the Temple in Jerusalem. This begs the question, would the King and priests in Judea take this lying down? I think not, and with the Torah not having transitioned from the oral to written form until the middle of the first millennium BCE, that left a lot of room for editing, or even creating Exodus out of whole cloth.

    I thought my idea that Jeroboam’s (2) golden calves preceded the one in Exodus was original, but it isn’t. There’s this reference from Wikipedia:
    “Richard Elliott Friedman, a biblical scholar and the Ann and Jay Davis Professor of Jewish Studies at the University of Georgia says, ‘at a minimum we can say that the writer of the golden calf account in Exodus seems to have taken the words that were traditionally ascribed to Jeroboam and placed them in the mouths of the people.’ Friedman believes that the story was turned into a polemic, exaggerating the throne platform decoration into idolatry, by a family of priests sidelined by Jeroboam.
    “The declarations of Aaron and Jeroboam are almost identical:
    • ‘These are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt’ (Exod 32:4, 8)’;
    • ‘Behold your gods, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt (1 Kings 12:28)'”

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


1 Responses

  1. Mahlon Marr says:

    The story of the Golden Calf in Exodus doesn’t make sense. The Israelites, who had just 2 months before been delivered from the Egyptians by the extraordinary supernatural events performed by God in the pillar of cloud and fire, were then worshipping a golden calf in the very presence of God in that pillar. Then centuries later, following the death of Solomon, Jeroboam broke Israel away from the united monarchy and set up two temples with golden calf idols in Bethel and Dan to be in competition with the Temple in Jerusalem. This begs the question, would the King and priests in Judea take this lying down? I think not, and with the Torah not having transitioned from the oral to written form until the middle of the first millennium BCE, that left a lot of room for editing, or even creating Exodus out of whole cloth.

    I thought my idea that Jeroboam’s (2) golden calves preceded the one in Exodus was original, but it isn’t. There’s this reference from Wikipedia:
    “Richard Elliott Friedman, a biblical scholar and the Ann and Jay Davis Professor of Jewish Studies at the University of Georgia says, ‘at a minimum we can say that the writer of the golden calf account in Exodus seems to have taken the words that were traditionally ascribed to Jeroboam and placed them in the mouths of the people.’ Friedman believes that the story was turned into a polemic, exaggerating the throne platform decoration into idolatry, by a family of priests sidelined by Jeroboam.
    “The declarations of Aaron and Jeroboam are almost identical:
    • ‘These are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt’ (Exod 32:4, 8)’;
    • ‘Behold your gods, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt (1 Kings 12:28)'”

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Send this to a friend