BIBLE HISTORY DAILY

Job Challenges God by Suing: God Responds

When Job questions God, Edward L. Greenstein finds precedence in Near Eastern legal texts

The Prophet Job. Photo: Nicola Lorusso.

After losing his health, wealth and children in inexplicable tragedies, the righteous and devout man Job questions God as to what he must have done to deserve such a heavy punishment. When he can think of nothing else, Job challenges God by suing God to provide evidence of his wrongdoing. Image: Alinari/Art Resource, NY.

Suing God. To most it would seem an absurd notion—but not to Job. After all, desperate times call for desperate measures.

The angel known as the Satan (Hebrew for “the adversary”), as told in the Book of Job, challenges God to test the devotion and piety of the righteous man Job. Job loses all of his worldly goods, his children and servants, as well as his health. Will he accept his fate or curse God?

Having been dealt such tremendous blows, Job and his companions can only assume that he has committed a grave sin to deserve such punishment, but Job can think of nothing he has done wrong. So, Job questions God about his transgression—why all these bad things have happened to him. Receiving no answer from the deity, Job finally decides that his only recourse is suing God.

As explained by Edward L. Greenstein in his article “When Job Sued God” in the May/June 2012 issue of Biblical Archaeology Review, Job understood the ancient legal system well. He knows that he cannot call witnesses in a lawsuit against God. So, lacking witness, he swears an exculpatory oath, as was standard in such legal cases in the ancient Near East. He swears to his own innocence and lists numerous wrongs that he has not committed. In doing so, Job challenges God to provide the evidence against him and prove his guilt.

Finally, God responds. But in legal terms, he throws out Job’s case on a technicality. In his oath, Job claimed to know everything about God and how the universe works, so God reprimands him. Where was Job, questions God, when he laid the earth’s foundations? If Job is so wise, he must have been present at creation, God adds sarcastically.

Job has no reply. By suing God, Job gets an answer, even if it isn’t the one he wanted.


The religion section of most bookstores includes an amazing array of Bibles. In our free eBook The Holy Bible: A Buyer’s Guide, prominent Biblical scholars Leonard Greenspoon and Harvey Minkoff expertly guide you through 21 different Bible translations (or versions) and address their content, text, style and religious orientation.

For more about how Job questions God and ends up suing God to get a response, read Edward L. Greenstein’s article “When Job Sued God” in the May/June 2012 issue of Biblical Archaeology Review.

Not a subscriber yet? Join today.


This Bible History Daily feature was originally published in April 2012.


The BAS Library includes online access to more than 9,000 articles by world-renowned experts and 22,000 gorgeous color photos from…

  • 45 years of Biblical Archaeology Review
  • 20 years of Bible Review, critical interpretations of Biblical texts
  • 8 years of Archaeology Odyssey, exploring the ancient roots of the Western world
  • The fully-searchable New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land, an authoritative work of the past century of archaeological study
  • Video lectures from world-renowned experts
  • Four books published by BAS and the Smithsonian Institution

Plus, you get access to so much more from your All-Access pass:

Biblical Archaeology Review print edition:

Enjoy the same current issues in glorious, traditional, full-color print …

  • One year of print issues of Biblical Archaeology Review magazine

Biblical Archaeology Review tablet edition:

Stay on top of the latest research! You get …

  • One year of issues of Biblical Archaeology Review magazine, all on your iPhone, iPad, Android, or Kindle Fire
  • Instant access to the complete tablet edition back-issue catalog of BAR from the January/February 2011 issue forward

All of this rich and detailed scholarship is available to you—right now—by buying a special All-Access pass.

That’s right: when you purchase your All-Access pass, you get a ticket to four decades of study, insight and discovery. Why not join us right now and start your own exploration?

Whether you’re researching a paper, preparing a sermon, deepening your understanding of Scripture or history, or simply marveling at the complexity of the Bible – the most important book in history—the BAS All-Access pass is an invaluable tool that cannot be matched anywhere else.

You'll get to experience all the discoveries and debate in beautiful clarity with Biblical Archaeology Review, anytime, anywhere! And the Library is fully searchable by topic, author, title and keyword, as well as the Special Collections like this one.

The All-Access pass is the way to explore Bible history and biblical archaeology.

Related Posts

Divine Love Painting
Jul 9
The Nephilim and the Sons of God

By: John Drummond

Jul 5
Did Pharaoh Sheshonq Attack Jerusalem?

By: Biblical Archaeology Society Staff

bamah-shiloh
Jun 27
High Places, Altars and the Bamah

By: Ellen White


9 Responses

  1. Rob Palmer says:

    I have always felt that graduates, unable to find work in their fields should have the basis to sue the learning institutions for taking their money with the implied work-related reward. Isn’t this, after all, simple fraud? From Trump University to the big ivy leaguers, why take money from poor people with the implied promise of a successful career? There is too long a history of this sort of thing. And today many students have a lifelong debt paying for the student loans. Let’s end the loans and keep more from being victimized. Yes, some schools will shut down and some professors will be laid off.

  2. bensone2 says:

    humor per excelence. a brilliant way to view/take the story of Job.

  3. Ryan McGinnis says:

    Are people insane? Has everyone gone mad?! Listen to this;
    “After losing his health, wealth and children in inexplicable tragedies, the righteous and devout man Job questions God as to what he must have done to deserve such a heavy punishment. When he can think of nothing else, Job challenges God by suing God to provide evidence of his wrongdoing.” This is a theory proposed by Edward L Greenstein, an ‘EDUCATED SCHOLAR!’

    Hello?! And these are the people that are ‘educating our professors, educators, and teachers?’ Run to darkness they have! Job (Yob) makes no such claim in his writings, nor does he EVER attempt to ‘sue Yahweh Elohym.’ The ideology behind ‘suing’ is a Roman law, invented BY the Romans, and we find no earlier case of ‘suing someone’ prior to the Romans. The absurdity that is our educational system is pathetic. And this is what you want to bring your children up under? Sorry, but Yahweh Elohym gave me a Moral Conscience, and the Knowledge to raise my own children, and not pass them off to some uneducated, demoralized babysitters!!

  4. Firestone says:

    Job had it pretty hard considering that he lost all his children ie: seven sons and three daughters including all livestock and servants and that’s not to mention his physical well being. Satan was definitely authorized by God to doing some serious damage which says a lot about the criminal acts of persecution. You want to be on your best behaviour by strictly obeying those perfect laws of liberation in the Bible. Whether you’re naughty or nice God will judge even though he’s not partial to anyone. 2Thess 1:3-10 & 1Pet 4:12-19 & 1Cor 4:9-13 all speak about God being fully responsible for persecuting his beloved children so that we can be worthy of his glorious kingdom. So next time Satan is doing something to ruin your life, MAYBE God authorized it. So be strong, stay strong and fight the good fight of faith because the Lord is our strength. Godbless.

  5. Patricia says:

    where did they come up with this conversatoion job was having with GOD is it in a scroll that has been found.

  6. RoseThistle says:

    God allowed satan to put Job through all that to help Job’s lost ‘friends’. His friends spent most of The Book of Job blaming God and blaming Job. They really kicked him hard when he was down.

    Read Job 42:7-10 KJV

  7. Kurt says:

    Job believed in the resurrection:
    It is painful to watch a loved one suffer and die. We naturally grieve such a loss. It is comforting to know, however, that our Creator, Jehovah God, understands our grief. More than that, he longs to use his almighty power to restore life to the dead. Notice the hope conveyed in the words of Job, recorded at Job 14:13-15.
    Consider the setting. Job, a man of outstanding faith, undergoes severe trials—including the loss of his material possessions, the death of all his beloved children, and a painful illness. In the throes of misery, he calls out to God: “O that in Sheol [mankind’s common grave] you would conceal me!” (Verse 13) Job sees Sheol as a welcome relief. There, as if a treasure hidden by God, he will be free of hardship and pain.*
    Will Sheol become Job’s permanent shelter? Job believes otherwise. He continues his prayer: “O that . . . you would set a time limit for me and remember me!” Job confidently hopes that his stay in Sheol will be temporary and that Jehovah will not forget him. Job likens the time that he will spend in Sheol to “compulsory service”—an enforced period of waiting. For how long? “Until my relief comes,” he says. (Verse 14) That relief will mean release from Sheol—in other words, a resurrection from the dead!
    Why is Job convinced that his relief will come? Because he knows how our loving Creator feels about His faithful worshippers who have died. Says Job: “You will call, and I myself shall answer you. For the work of your hands you will have a yearning.” (Verse 15) Job acknowledges that he is the work of God’s hands. The Life-Giver who was responsible for Job’s formation in the womb can certainly restore him to life after he has died.—Job 10:8, 9; 31:15.
    Read more in 701 languages here:http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200273131

  8. Ken Chan says:

    Job 42:1-6

  9. Glenn Williams says:

    This quote:
    “In his oath, Job claimed to know everything about God and how the universe works”

    What scripture is that referring to?

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


9 Responses

  1. Rob Palmer says:

    I have always felt that graduates, unable to find work in their fields should have the basis to sue the learning institutions for taking their money with the implied work-related reward. Isn’t this, after all, simple fraud? From Trump University to the big ivy leaguers, why take money from poor people with the implied promise of a successful career? There is too long a history of this sort of thing. And today many students have a lifelong debt paying for the student loans. Let’s end the loans and keep more from being victimized. Yes, some schools will shut down and some professors will be laid off.

  2. bensone2 says:

    humor per excelence. a brilliant way to view/take the story of Job.

  3. Ryan McGinnis says:

    Are people insane? Has everyone gone mad?! Listen to this;
    “After losing his health, wealth and children in inexplicable tragedies, the righteous and devout man Job questions God as to what he must have done to deserve such a heavy punishment. When he can think of nothing else, Job challenges God by suing God to provide evidence of his wrongdoing.” This is a theory proposed by Edward L Greenstein, an ‘EDUCATED SCHOLAR!’

    Hello?! And these are the people that are ‘educating our professors, educators, and teachers?’ Run to darkness they have! Job (Yob) makes no such claim in his writings, nor does he EVER attempt to ‘sue Yahweh Elohym.’ The ideology behind ‘suing’ is a Roman law, invented BY the Romans, and we find no earlier case of ‘suing someone’ prior to the Romans. The absurdity that is our educational system is pathetic. And this is what you want to bring your children up under? Sorry, but Yahweh Elohym gave me a Moral Conscience, and the Knowledge to raise my own children, and not pass them off to some uneducated, demoralized babysitters!!

  4. Firestone says:

    Job had it pretty hard considering that he lost all his children ie: seven sons and three daughters including all livestock and servants and that’s not to mention his physical well being. Satan was definitely authorized by God to doing some serious damage which says a lot about the criminal acts of persecution. You want to be on your best behaviour by strictly obeying those perfect laws of liberation in the Bible. Whether you’re naughty or nice God will judge even though he’s not partial to anyone. 2Thess 1:3-10 & 1Pet 4:12-19 & 1Cor 4:9-13 all speak about God being fully responsible for persecuting his beloved children so that we can be worthy of his glorious kingdom. So next time Satan is doing something to ruin your life, MAYBE God authorized it. So be strong, stay strong and fight the good fight of faith because the Lord is our strength. Godbless.

  5. Patricia says:

    where did they come up with this conversatoion job was having with GOD is it in a scroll that has been found.

  6. RoseThistle says:

    God allowed satan to put Job through all that to help Job’s lost ‘friends’. His friends spent most of The Book of Job blaming God and blaming Job. They really kicked him hard when he was down.

    Read Job 42:7-10 KJV

  7. Kurt says:

    Job believed in the resurrection:
    It is painful to watch a loved one suffer and die. We naturally grieve such a loss. It is comforting to know, however, that our Creator, Jehovah God, understands our grief. More than that, he longs to use his almighty power to restore life to the dead. Notice the hope conveyed in the words of Job, recorded at Job 14:13-15.
    Consider the setting. Job, a man of outstanding faith, undergoes severe trials—including the loss of his material possessions, the death of all his beloved children, and a painful illness. In the throes of misery, he calls out to God: “O that in Sheol [mankind’s common grave] you would conceal me!” (Verse 13) Job sees Sheol as a welcome relief. There, as if a treasure hidden by God, he will be free of hardship and pain.*
    Will Sheol become Job’s permanent shelter? Job believes otherwise. He continues his prayer: “O that . . . you would set a time limit for me and remember me!” Job confidently hopes that his stay in Sheol will be temporary and that Jehovah will not forget him. Job likens the time that he will spend in Sheol to “compulsory service”—an enforced period of waiting. For how long? “Until my relief comes,” he says. (Verse 14) That relief will mean release from Sheol—in other words, a resurrection from the dead!
    Why is Job convinced that his relief will come? Because he knows how our loving Creator feels about His faithful worshippers who have died. Says Job: “You will call, and I myself shall answer you. For the work of your hands you will have a yearning.” (Verse 15) Job acknowledges that he is the work of God’s hands. The Life-Giver who was responsible for Job’s formation in the womb can certainly restore him to life after he has died.—Job 10:8, 9; 31:15.
    Read more in 701 languages here:http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200273131

  8. Ken Chan says:

    Job 42:1-6

  9. Glenn Williams says:

    This quote:
    “In his oath, Job claimed to know everything about God and how the universe works”

    What scripture is that referring to?

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Send this to a friend