Agamemnon Tselikas: Response to Allan J. Pantuck

Did Morton Smith Forge “Secret Mark”?

Back to Did Morton Smith Forge “Secret Mark”?

The controversial text that Smith discovered was a Greek manuscript written on the endpages of a 17th-century book. The apparently 18th-century handwriting recorded a copy of a previously unknown letter from Clement of Alexandria to someone named Theodore.

Dear Mr. Hershel,

I wish you to be in good health.

I read the article you sent me about the criticism made by Dr. Alan Pantuck of my report on the manuscript of Clement. I have only one remark: that Dr. Pantuck restricts his criticism only to one section, while not taking into account either the textological observations or the facts on the presence of the Ignatius edition in the library of Mar Saba. I respect the opinion of anybody, but I do not proceed to such personal criticism. Anyone who has a critical ability must have his opinion itself without any influence. I’ve written previously to you that without any bias I did my research on this topic. I spent much of my precious time for many days and many dozen of hours, here in Athens and in Jerusalem, to contribute my scientific experience and means in order to enlighten the issue. The resulting comments and opinion I exposed in my report. Of course some agree or disagree. But most certainly I have no interest in the opinion of those who, without scientific basis and method, write several non-existent and fantastic things in their blogs. To me these are parasites of real and true science.

With deep respect to you,

Agamemnon Tselikas

Related Posts

Dante Inferno
Jun 21
Who Is Satan?

By: John Gregory Drummond

May 24
The Virgin Mary and the Prophet Muhammad

By: Mary Joan Winn Leith

The Pyramin of Pharaoh Djoser
May 17
Pharaoh’s Brick Makers

By: Marek Dospěl

May 14
First Person: Misogyny in the Bible

By: Hershel Shanks

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Send this to a friend