Can we prevent archaeological looting?
This Bible History Daily feature was originally published in 2015.—Ed.
Archaeological looting is a global issue that threatens the preservation of our shared cultural heritage. In the Middle East, archaeological looting and the deliberate destruction of archaeological sites and monuments amid ongoing warfare have captured international attention. Antiquities looted from sites in Syria and northern Iraq and subsequently trafficked are one of the main sources of funding for the Islamic State, the Sunni extremist group referred to as ISIS or ISIL. What, if anything, can be done to protect these objects and sites?
In “Is It Possible to Protect Our Cultural Heritage?” in the March/April 2015 issue of Biblical Archaeology Review, BAR editor Hershel Shanks examines local and international efforts to address the archaeological looting and devastation of sites in the Middle East. In Shanks’s view, these efforts, while laudable, have thus far been ineffective in protecting cultural property.
Continuous conflict has left thousands of archaeological sites in Syria and Iraq—including those of the Bronze, Iron, Greek, Roman, Byzantine and Islamic periods—vulnerable. The culturally diverse ancient city of Dura-Europos, where one of the earliest Christian house-churches was discovered, has been heavily pillaged over the past few years. In July 2014, ISIS militants blew up the mosque that housed the traditional tomb of the prophet Jonah in Mosul, Iraq. According to a report from September 2014, five of the six World Heritage sites in Syria “exhibit significant damage” due to ongoing warfare.
Dig into more than 9,000 articles in the Biblical Archaeology Society’s vast library plus much more with an All-Access pass.
Cultural heritage experts believe that ISIS militants have been responsible for much of the archaeological looting going on in Syria and northern Iraq since the rise of the rebel group. Criminal networks seeking to profit from the turmoil, however, are also to blame. The Art Newspaper reports that there has been a 133% rise in Syrian objects imported into the United States.
Trafficking in antiquities has been compared to other lucrative criminal enterprises, including the drugs and arms trade. Read more about the antiquities market in “Sold to the Highest Bidder: Antiquities as Cash Cows.”
How effective would the placement of guards be for on-the-ground protection of vulnerable archaeological sites in this region? A story recounted in the New York Times offers a glimpse of the danger of such a situation: Maamoun Abdulkarim, director general of antiquities and museums in Damascus, relayed the tragic fate of a ranger who guarded several sites in the eastern Syrian city of Deir al-Zour—he was beheaded.
There are myriad efforts by professionals, government organizations and concerned citizens to address the loss of cultural heritage in conflict areas. The Safeguarding the Heritage of Syria Initiative is building a database to document the destruction of Syrian sites and artifacts—thus preserving at least the memory of cultural treasures. The Combatant Command Cultural Heritage Action Group trains U.S. military personnel to protect cultural property during operations. The International Council of Museums published the Emergency Red List of Syrian Cultural Objects at Risk to make art and heritage professionals and law enforcement officials aware of looted Syrian antiquities that may resurface in the art market.
In his BAR article, Shanks remarks, “While we should applaud those who are devoting themselves to protecting cultural property, there seems to be no effective means to prevent the destruction amid the turmoil gripping the Middle East. Much of the professional effort is devoted to documenting the destruction, rather than preventing it.”
In the face of this bleak—but frank—sentiment, it is nevertheless commendable that greater awareness is being raised for the value of our shared cultural heritage. Greater awareness can inspire more vigilance and better ideas for the protection of cultural property.
Speaking at the “Heritage in Peril: Iraq and Syria” event at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York on September 22, 2014, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said, “The fight to protect the cultural heritage of Iraq and Syria isn’t just about shared values. It’s about protecting a shared legacy […] ISIS forces the people of Iraq and Syria to pay for their cultural heritage in blood. We are determined instead to help Iraqis and Syrians protect and preserve their heritage in peace. That’s our common responsibility.”
Learn more about the archaeological looting of sites in the Middle East by reading the full article “Is It Possible to Protect Our Cultural Heritage?” by Hershel Shanks in the March/April 2015 issue of BAR.
Not a BAS Library member yet? Join the BAS Library today.
Biblical History at What Cost?
Hobby Lobby, the Museum of the Bible and the antiquities market
The Antiquities Market—A “Cat and Mouse Game”
ISIS Destroys Antiquities in Mosul, Iraq
ISIS Captures Syrian City of Palmyra
ISIS Plants Explosives in Ancient City of Palmyra
Temple of Baal Shamin in Palmyra Blown Up by ISIS
Digital Humanities and the Ancient World
Sold to the Highest Bidder: Antiquities as Cash Cows
Endangered Heritage: Archaeological Looting in Turkey
This Bible History Daily feature was originally published on February 23, 2015.
Sign up to receive our email newsletter and never miss an update.
Dig into the illuminating world of the Bible with a BAS All-Access membership. Combine a one-year tablet and print subscription to BAR with membership in the BAS Library to start your journey into the ancient past today!Subscribe Today
Gwen is correct. Look how statues and such across the old South are being removed on the grounds they are offensive. See how the Ten Commandments fare, too. If one person is offended, the object is removed for fear of a multi-million dollar law suit.
In the United States, the heckler gets his veto in. Cultural objects be damned.
Because nobody said a word 10-15 years ago about the Muslim desecration of the Temple Mount with Bulldozers and ditch digging to put in power lines, the IAD, Israeli Antiquities Dept just sat like beaten dogs and said nothing nor the Supreme Court. So now you wonder why they feel free to destroy what they wish. Like the Buddhas that the Taliban got away with destroying and the world shut its mouth. Mida Keneged Mida.
Nobody did anything but gave useless talk so neither today will anybody say anything.
The ONLY way to stop such destruction is to use Napalm and Phosphorous bombs on identified Daesh/IS forces occupying the vicinity of these World Heritage sites. Napalm and phosphorous are terrible weapons, designed to kill victims by burning deep into the skin, but it is justifiable against such greed-driven extremists such as Daesh. These incendary bombs are not high-explosive and theerefore will not cause damage to the entirely fireproof remains above ground such as sandstone columns, pediments, ashlars, etc.
Other alternative weapons of annihilation which could be used include gas weapons or even the Neutron Bomb, which was designed by the Americans in the 1980’s to kill enemy forces but to leave cities, buildings and infrastructure in enemy occupied territory intact. Just ONE Neutron Bomb could annihilate ALL of Daesh forces occupying a given area (e.g. Raqqa), but is best targeted where a minimum of innocent people may be also killed.
Many of these weapons, such as poison gas and Napalm/Phosphorous, may also have to be un-banned by some kind of temporary suspension of international treaties against Chemical Weapons, but I know that the majority of those concerned about priceless cultural treasures will be OK about that, and limited return to use of Chemical Weapons will just have to be tolerated as a reality in the 21st Century. Finally, safeguards AGAINST EVER using Biological Weapons will have to be STRENGTHENED, as these are far more dangerous than any chemical weapon in terms of ‘containment’.
Expect an U.N. condemnation, of course, blaming Israel- as that is what the U.N is best at. 450,000 dead in Syria, countless archaeological sites destroyed either deliberately or as a result of war. But Israel which protects all its archaeological sites will be some how be blamed for damaging Palestinian sensibilities, whatever that is, and using excessive force and killing innocent Palestinians, that is errorists.
The sooner we exterminate Daesh, Al Qaida, their ilk and all their supporters, the better chance the artifacts can be saved.
Ceterum censeo, delenda est Daesh
James: The US is not safe anymore, look what they are doing to own history with the same sentiment of being “offended”. It is a disgrace that one culture rooted in violence and destruction is able to move so quickly to destroy the beauty of any of those who do not fit their personal agenda. It is getting bad here and will only get worse unless sudden enlightenment strikes. This seems unlikely.
I am saddened by the insane destruction of antiquities in Iraq and Syria. We saw the same in Afghanistan a few years ago. These are monuments I will never be able to see in person.
The Middle East is so unstable that all antiquities there are at risk. If this iconoclasm spreads, then antiquities in many Asian countries are also at risk. The United States is the safest place for antiquities to reside, both in museums and in individual collections.
In the elite academic world, all who own antiquities are wealthy and are worthy of disdain. This is untrue. There are many who sacrifice to own a part of the past. Rabid zealots would deny them the right.
ISIL destroys what it can’t sell. At this point, is it better for them to sell them illicitly or to see the antiquities be destroyed?
[…] Some more thoughts on how to prevent the looting of archaeological sites. […]
Iraq: Isis take sledgehammers to priceless Assyrian artefacts at Mosul museum [VIDEO]
The Islamic State (Isis) has published a video showing militants destroying ancient artefacts in a Mosul museum with sledgehammer and pickaxes.
IS fighters are seen unveiling old statues in the Ninawa museum dating back to the Assyrian empire and then dragging them down to the ground, where they fall into pieces.
Then, they are depicted pounding 3,000-year-old sculptures with hammers until they are completely shattered. Tens of militants are seen using ladders, hammers and drills to destroy every statue in the museum, including a winged-bull Assyrian protective deity dating back to the 7th century BC. Read more:
So sad. So many artifacts that tell us so much about where we come from and who we are the value of artifacts is so much more than money I think that more bloodshed to protect these artifacts is not the answer but I do think that is is needs to be stopped at all they are doing. I think that it’s time to end their reign of terror
Sadly, I don’t see a good end to any of this; Kerry says we’re determined to protect the cultural heritage in peace, but there isn’t, and isn’t going to be, any peace.
The same goes for both sides; if they have no respect for human life, of what value are the fruits of that life, other than as a profit center, for which I have no doubt there are equally callous buyers who just want to own cultural artifacts as if they deserved them.