There are hundreds of passages in the Bible that describe food, drink and dining. Many biblical stories are set within the context of a meal. While most of these are about regular meals, others refer to more bizarre, extreme or supernatural cases of eating and drinking.
Here are 10 of the most notable examples (in no specific order):
Gold Powder
When Moses sees the Israelites worshiping the golden calf he grinds the idol into a fine powder, mixes it with water and forces the people to drink (Exodus 32:19–20).
Scroll of Lamentations
God gives Ezekiel a two-sided scroll of Lamentations to eat. Ezekiel fills his stomach and finds the scroll to be “as sweet as honey” (Ezekiel 2:8–3:3).
Bread and Excrement
God tells Ezekiel to eat bread baked upon human excrement but Ezekiel gets away with bread baked upon animal excrement. Unlike the scroll, we aren’t told how it tastes (Ezekiel 4:10-17).
The Manna
The Israelites survive for forty years in the desert on daily provisions of manna (Exodus 16:35). The name manna reportedly comes from the question the Israelites asked, man hu⁾, “What is it?” (Exodus 16:15). Although some commentators prefer a naturalistic answer to this question, e.g., manna is the gum resin of desert shrubs, the Biblical text presents the manna as a miracle food. It falls six days a week but not on the Sabbath, disintegrates when it is stored and stops falling when the Israelites enter the land of Canaan. Manna is even called “the grain of heaven,” “the bread of heaven” or “the bread of angels” in a number of Hebrew Bible, New Testament and apocryphal texts (Psalms 78:24, 105:40; John 6:31; 2 Esdras 1:19).
Animal Fodder for a King In accordance with Daniel’s prophecy, Nebuchadnezzar the king of Babylon lives in the wilderness for seven years eating grass like an ox (Dan 4:33). A similar story appears in 2 Esdras (9:23-27, 12:51) where Ezra sustains himself on a diet of flowers for seven days. Interestingly, a number of scholars suggest that the story of Nebuchadnezzar is actually based on Nabonidus, the king of Babylon who spent a decade of his life at an oasis in the Arabian wilderness.
40-Day Superfoods An angel gives Elijah a cake and some water and it is enough to sustain him for a forty-day journey from Beersheba to Mount Horeb/Sinai, where he encounters God in a cave (1 Kings 19:3–9).
Become a BAS All-Access Member Now!
Read Biblical Archaeology Review online, explore 50 years of BAR, watch videos, attend talks, and more
The Fantastic Fruits of Eden There were two supernatural trees in the Garden of Eden, each with its own fruit. The tree of knowledge bestowed a divine knowledge of good and bad, making one like the gods. The tree of life granted immortality (Genesis 3:22).
Food from Nowhere A number of Biblical figures are saved from thirst and starvation in the barrenness of the desert. For example, Hagar and Ishmael are shown a hidden well by God (Genesis 21:14–19), Moses finds water in a desert rock (Numbers 20:11), and Elijah is given bread and meat twice a day by ravens in the desert (1 Kings 17:1–6).
Human Flesh Cannibalism on account of hunger is perhaps the most extreme punishment in the Hebrew Bible. It is at times described in vivid detail, e.g., in the threat of Deuteronomy 28 that fathers and mothers will eat their own children in secrecy so that they do not have to share the meat (Deuteronomy 28:53–57).
Free Refills There are a number of stories about the miracles performed by the prophets Elijah and Elisha. According to the Book of Kings, a hungry woman’s jar of flour and jug of oil refilled themselves until a famine subsided (1 Kings 17:10-16), a poor woman’s single jug of oil was able to fill the many vessels of her neighbors (2 Kings 4:1–7), and a man’s twenty loaves of bread were miraculously able to feed one hundred hungry men with some left over (2 Kings 4:42–44). A similar story appears in John 6, where Jesus feeds five thousand men with five barley loaves and two small fish. Again, there is still food left over.
This Bible History Daily article, “The 10 Strangest Foods in the Bible,” was originally published on May 6, 2014.
David Z. Moster, PhD, is a Research Fellow in Hebrew Bible at Brooklyn College and a Lecturer in Rabbinics at Nyack College. He is the author of the upcoming book Etrog: How a Chinese Fruit Became a Jewish Symbol (Palgrave Macmillan, 2018). He wrote The 10 Strangest Foods in the Bible in 2014. His websites are www.929chapters.com and brooklyn-cuny.academia.edu/DavidMoster.
The world of the Bible is knowable. We can learn about the society where the ancient Israelites, and later Jesus and the Apostles, lived through the modern discoveries that provide us clues.
Biblical Archaeology Review is the guide on that fascinating journey. Here is your ticket to join us as we discover more and more about the biblical world and its people.
Each issue of Biblical Archaeology Review features lavishly illustrated and easy-to-understand articles such as:
• Fascinating finds from the Hebrew Bible and New Testament periods
• The latest scholarship by the world's greatest archaeologists and distinguished scholars
• Stunning color photographs, informative maps, and diagrams
• BAR's unique departments
• Reviews of the latest books on biblical archaeology
The BAS Digital Library includes:
• 45+ years of Biblical Archaeology Review
• 20+ years of Bible Review online, providing critical interpretations of biblical texts
• 8 years of Archaeology Odyssey online, exploring the ancient roots of the Western world in a scholarly and entertaining way,
• The New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land
• Video lectures from world-renowned experts.
• Access to 50+ curated Special Collections,
• Four highly acclaimed books, published in conjunction with the Smithsonian Institution: Aspects of Monotheism, Feminist Approaches to the Bible, The Rise of Ancient Israel and The Search for Jesus.
Cow chips, camel chips, dried horse apples and so on. It leaves no taste if it is dried, no smoke, either. Sheep, burro, and goat. Do not never ever use it from predators, no matter how well dried and seared in the sun. That contains a very nasty fungus we call witch powder, AKA to archaeologists, King Tut’s revenge. Walk in beauty.
I would ask: If G-D is not the author of confusion ; why is he attributed to so much controversy and debate on literal vs. symbolism in Scripture? How do we differentiate ?
I would comment : ONE FOOD WE ARE OFTEN FORCED TO EAT AS BIBLICAL STUDENTS IS THE ARROGANT CRUMBS BENEATH THE CRITIC’S POSTED COMMENTS. wow. Some morsels are hard to digest lol
Donna . ( wonderful work on your Blog!!!! I love your writings!)
Thanks David for not dismissing manna as gum resin. I don’t think the Israelites would have said “What is it?” if it was simply tree sap. And it would have taken a lot of tree sap to feed a nation for 40 years. A miracle is a miracle.
Hi all. Just here to throw a wrench. I love and respect the wonderful education and discussion. Paul, all the food references are being mixed up. Some are literal and some metaphoric. As far as the trees in the Garden…..it’s too late, we bit the big one. Let the games begin. We know that in our early History mans bodies were different than ours now. When you go back to the beginning of man our air on this planet was different also. In the beginning our bodies were rugged to survive terra firma. We truly ingested a more rugged diet. Our teeth and bones say so. The problem is that man identified with apes instead of understanding the levity of our enviorment when we were first created. We had the brains however we assume that because their bodies were rugged that they were brainless and the Father was not with us. Then he started the genetic engineering through a man called Abram. At the time he and his people were just another race on the planet. Understand, it could have been an oriental, it could have been any race at that time. But it was Abram who was best suited for the Fathers work. Then began the teaching of Abram by the Father. When Joseph was taken into Slavery into Egypt the genetic engineering began. Look at it. A man was even struck dead by the Father for letting his issue go onto the ground. Just look! With this change in our bodies our food was changed through the Levitical laws after Moses. Then the real intelligence of mankind began and our bodies became such that could support strong spirit. Such as the Christ whoes body and spirit were complete. In fact, the body could not hold strong spirit until the resurrection of Christ and he left us with the Paracliese. We could finally hold strong spirit. God Bless us in our search for Truth.
Ezekiel baking bread using a fire made of animal dung is nothing unusual. Dried animal dung has been used for fires ever since humans discovered how to use fire. The pioneers moving west over the Great Plains in the 19th Century, traveled in Conestoga wagons. Under the wagon was fastened a heavy piece of cloth and as the wagon train traveled, the women and children would collect dried “buffalo chips” and place them in the cloth. When stopped and fires were made, the buffalo chips were used as fuel.
Actually, the Genesis account does not teach that these trees had any peculiar or supernatural powers of their own. Rather, they were actual trees that Jehovah invested with symbolic meaning.
What, then, did the two trees symbolize? Many complex theories have been put forward. The genuine answer, while simple, is quite profound. The tree of the knowledge of good and bad represented a privilege that is God’s province alone—the right to determine what is good and what is bad. (Jeremiah 10:23) No wonder it was a crime to steal from that tree! The tree of life, on the other hand, represented a gift that only God can bestow—everlasting life.—Romans 6:23.
The web link provided to a pdf in my previous comment (#2) is no longer available for free. “Chemically-Induced Visions in the Fourth Book of Ezra in Light of Comparative Persian Material” explains how Jewish visionary accounts in such works as the Fourth Book of Ezra (also referred to as 2 Esdras, 9:23-29, 12:51, 14:38-48) and in “Martyrdom of Isaiah” (2:7-11) describe a mind-altering experience as a result of ingesting certain psychotropic plants that were patterned after Zoroastrian writings and were probably written after 70 C.E. This tradition, however, can be traced back to the period of Greek influence following the conquest by Alexander the Great when it became a virtue to abstain from meat and wine and subsist on vegetables (Daniel 1:8-15). Vincente Dobroruka writes:
“In the first passage, 4Ezra 9:23-29, we have a dialogue between God and Ezra where the seer is still perplexed about the fate of the wicked in relation to the righteous. For God to explain in further detail to Ezra why so many will perish while He is only concerned about hte fate of the just. He orders Ezra to go to a field without any human construction and not fast, but instead eat only the flowers of the field and abstain from meat or wine (4Ezra 9:23-25).
‘But if you let seven days more pass – do not fast during them, however; but go into a field of flowers where no house has been built, and eat only the flowers of the field, and taste no meat and drink no wine, but eat only flowers, and pray to then Most High continually – then I will come and talk with you.’
Here again the theme of vegetarianism is present (maybe as a reminder of the pre-diluvian diet that man enjoyed once, thus closer to Edenic times), but hte reference to the eating of flowers alone is striking and even absent from some versions of the text…” http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/ancient-cultures/ancient-israel/cache-of-jewelry-coins-of-alexander-the-great-israel/
It’s not food made upon human excrement in Ezekiel. It is food cooked on a FIRE that is MADE from excrement. Please, if you are going to quote the Bible get it correct. There’s a huge difference in the two.
In response to Judith’s inquiry about the trial by ordeal of a woman suspected of adultery known as Sotah (Numbers 5:11-31), it is based on a word that means “turn aside,” and in this case refers to iniquity. In a book of mysticism known as the Bahir, there is a play on words between ‘satah’ (iniquity) with the letter teth (soft ‘t’) and ‘satah’ (conceal) with the letter tau (hard ‘t’) that is found in Genesis 38:15, where Judah mistakens Tamar for a prostitute after she conceals (satah) her face.
“The word Satan means ‘turning aside,’ since he turns all the world aside to the balance of guilt. How is this indicated? It is written (Genesis 38:16), ‘And he turned aside to her,’ and the Targum renders this VaSata, [Satah being the root of Satan[. It is likewise written (Proverbs 4:15), ‘Turn aside (S’teh) from it and pass on'” (The Bahir, by Aryeh Kaplan, p.62).
In other words, get on with your studies and don’t emulate the self-appointed “vice police” who are always on the lookout for women who wear make-up so they might defile themselves by physically touching the women in order to wipe off the lipstick, thereby making themselves a laughing-stock like Judah who only proved that women are more worthy to hold the very office that the men themselves have prostituted.
The author has the benefit of knowing the Jewish traditions to be able to compose such an article. No offence intended but I think it’s ironic how this scholar’s trajectary began at YU along the upscale upper east side of Manhattan, where outsides its gates the socially accepted alchohol culture dominates portrayed in the log-running televsion sit-com “Cheers” (where everybody knows your name, and the episodes are all the same). Then on to NYU in the leafy heart of The Village where it is not so upscale so as to clinicly sterilize any reference to the “cattle herb” that Jews living in exile in Babylonia would have been familiar with as farm laborers and were in a class designated in an old Sumerian tablet as the “knocked-down kicked-under people.”
In “Food of the Gods; The Search For the Original Tree of Knowledge” by Terence McKenna, the origin of this mysterious plant that gives knowledge of the divine realm began with psychoactive mushroom cults form Africa and Europe as well as the milky-white juice Soma (probably ground up cannabis and ephedrin) of the Indo-Europeans from Central Asia, and was eventually replaced with, not suprisingly, alchohol (where everybody knows your name, and all your secrets just the same). On page 141 a quote is given from”Water and Wine” by E.S. Drower:
“Fruits rich in seed, such as pomegranates and figs, appear from the earliest times as symbols of fecundity. The vine and its juice has a long history of religious significance. Deified, like the Zoroastrian haoma and Vedic soma, its powers of exhilaration and intoxication were thought to be manistefations of divine possession. In the group of sacraments or ‘mysteries’ that we shall examine,…the vine symbolizes especially the fruitfullness of woman, and its juice, mostly unfermented, is drunk ceremonially in order to promote the ferility of the womb.”
Perhaps the tradition of Soma use was preserved in Genesis 49:12; “His eyes are darker than wine, his teeth are whiter than milk.”
@Benny. I can’t vouch for a YU education but to be fair what point has the author missed? His statement is basically a direct quote of Gen 3:22 which is represented as God’s own declaration.
Peace.
Dairy Products and Beverages. Also important as food were milk and milk products, using milk of cows, goats, or sheep. (1Sa 17:18) Milk was normally kept in skin bottles. (Jg 4:19) It would sour quickly. The Hebrew word chem·ʼah′, translated “butter,” can also mean “curdled milk.” Cheese was also a well-known item. In fact, the Tyropoeon (Cheesemakers’) Valley ran along the W side of the very early city of Jerusalem.—Jg 5:25; 2Sa 17:29; Job 10:10; see CHEESE. http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200001541#h=16:0-16:861
Bread of life:
When God created Adam, he proceeded to “blow into his nostrils the breath [form of nesha·mah′] of life, and the man came to be a living soul.” (Ge 2:7) This “breath of life” not only filled the lungs with air but also imparted to the body the life-force that is sustained by breathing. The breath being drawn into the body through the nostrils is essential to life; it sustains the life-force. At the Flood, “everything in which the breath of the force of life was active in its nostrils, namely, all that were on the dry ground, died.”—Ge 7:22. http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200270933
Hidden manna:
Christ also used the jar of manna symbolically when he assured his spirit-anointed followers that those who prove to be conquerors would receive “the hidden manna,” an imperishable food supply or that which results from such a supply, in their case, immortality and incorruptibility in heaven.—Re 2:17; 1Co 15:53.http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200273643
For me, the strangest but most wonderful food is the Bread of life (John 6:48, 51), if any man eats from this bread, he shall live forever.
Another strange food is the hidden manna (Rev 2:17)
The creation story in the second chapter of Genesis is older than the account given in the first chapter and it has many parallels in Sumerian mythology. One such myth is called “Cattle and Grain” and is described in Samuel Kramer’s “Sumerian Mythology,” p.53:
“The myth involving Lahar, the cattle god, and his sister Anshan, the grain goddess, represents another variation of the Cain-Abel motif in Near East mythology. Lahar and Anshan, according to our myth, were created in the creation chamber of the gods in order that the Anunnaki, the children and followers of the heaven god An, might have food to eat and clothes to wear. But the Anunnaki were unable to make effective use of the products of these deities; it was to remedy this situation that man was created.”
Here we can compare the situation of the heavenly gods being dependent on the products of earth, as “in the day Yahweh Elohim made the earth and heaven (Genesis 2:4). Note that the earth is mentioned before heaven . Kramer provides an introduction to this myth (p.72):
“After on the mountain of heaven and earth,
An (the heaven god) had caused the Anunnaki (his followers) to be born,
Because the name Anshan (the grain-goddess) had not been born, had not been fashioned,
Because Uttu (a name associated with a spider web, alluding to the spinning of fabric) had not been fashioned,
Because to Uttu no temenos (shrine) had been set up,
There was no ewe, no lamb was dropped,
There was no goat, no kid was dropped…”
Compare this with “there was no shrub (syach) of the field, there was no herb (asub) of the field” (Genesis 2:5), where the shrub is human food (grain) and the herb is animal feed.
The correct term for’herb’ in Genesis 2:5 is ‘asub’ and in Daniel 4:29-30 it is ‘asuba’ and in Dueteronomy 11:15, it is Yahweh, not Sin, who “wiil provide herbage in the fields for your cattle – and thus you shall eat your fill”
In response to Alex it is the “cattle herb” in Daniel 4:30. About 1000 B.C.E in Judah that is the herb (asa) that the animals eat follows the shrub (shyach) in Genesis 2:5, which is the plant that is modified for human consumption such as wheat. After the Jews returned to their homeland in the 5th century B.C.E., they brought with them a version of creation based on soma-induced visions of the prophet Zoroarster and being an agrarian society (settled), the Jews added their own categories of plants beginning with the amoeba-sprout then grass then herb and is therefore not a fruit-bearing tree (Genesis 1:11).
Perhaps this why the Akkadian moon god Sin was worhiped all over the Arabian and Sinai deserts:
“Sin was also held to be wise and was believed to measure time with his waxing and waning. Moreover, by raising the marsh waters around the city of Ur, where his temple stood, he ensured the well-being of cattle by enabling them to ejoy an abundant supply of food” (“The Ultimate Encyclopedia of Mythology” by Arthur Cotterell & Rachel Storm, p. 319).
“There is a place in Arabia more or less opposite the city of Buto, where I went to try to get information about the flying snakes. On my arrival I saw their skeletons in incalculable numbers; they were piled in heaps, some of which were big, others smaller, others smaller still, and there were many piles of them. The place where these bones lie is a narrow mountain pass leading to a broad plain which joins on to the plain of Egypt, and it is said that when the winged snakes fly to Egypt from Arabia in spring, the ibises meet them at the entrance to the pass and do not let them get through, but kill them. According to the Arabians, the service is the reason for the great reference with which the Ibis is regarded in Egypt” (Herodotus, “The Histories” Book Two para. 75).
Fortunately Benny, there are people who are not scholars and thus have no reputation to uphold and who can interpret the meaning of the tree of knowlege without fearing they could let everyone down by deviating ever so slightly from tradition. The story of Nebuchadnezer eating grass like cattle (Daniel 4:30) refers to the last king of the Babylonian empire, Nabonidus, who some scholars beleive was an archaeologist who, having possibly discovered an ancient tradition regarding the moon god Sin, embarked on a mission to restore the primacy of this ancient Arabian deity originally associated with nomadic cattle herders (there was always this connection between the moon and plant growth). As for the reference to 2 Esdras 9:26, this refers to the ingestion of certain plants immediately prior to receiving a vision (in this instance, that of a woman who is the personification of Zion):
“So I went, as he directed me, into the field which is called Ardat; and there I sat among the flowers and ate of the plants of the field, and the nourshment they afforded satisfied me.”
There is an interesting pdf that Yeshiva University students can download that connects these scriptural references to psychotropic plants: http://www.pej-unb.org/downloads/art_4ezra.pdf
Sign up to receive our email newsletter and never miss an update.
All-Access Membership
All-Access Membership
Dig into the illuminating world of the Bible with a BAS All-Access Membership. Get your print subscription to BAR and your online access to the BAS Library—as well as FREE online talks and Travel/Study discounts. Start your journey into the biblical past today!
Cow chips, camel chips, dried horse apples and so on. It leaves no taste if it is dried, no smoke, either. Sheep, burro, and goat. Do not never ever use it from predators, no matter how well dried and seared in the sun. That contains a very nasty fungus we call witch powder, AKA to archaeologists, King Tut’s revenge. Walk in beauty.
I would ask: If G-D is not the author of confusion ; why is he attributed to so much controversy and debate on literal vs. symbolism in Scripture? How do we differentiate ?
I would comment : ONE FOOD WE ARE OFTEN FORCED TO EAT AS BIBLICAL STUDENTS IS THE ARROGANT CRUMBS BENEATH THE CRITIC’S POSTED COMMENTS. wow. Some morsels are hard to digest lol
Donna . ( wonderful work on your Blog!!!! I love your writings!)
Thanks David for not dismissing manna as gum resin. I don’t think the Israelites would have said “What is it?” if it was simply tree sap. And it would have taken a lot of tree sap to feed a nation for 40 years. A miracle is a miracle.
Hi all. Just here to throw a wrench. I love and respect the wonderful education and discussion. Paul, all the food references are being mixed up. Some are literal and some metaphoric. As far as the trees in the Garden…..it’s too late, we bit the big one. Let the games begin. We know that in our early History mans bodies were different than ours now. When you go back to the beginning of man our air on this planet was different also. In the beginning our bodies were rugged to survive terra firma. We truly ingested a more rugged diet. Our teeth and bones say so. The problem is that man identified with apes instead of understanding the levity of our enviorment when we were first created. We had the brains however we assume that because their bodies were rugged that they were brainless and the Father was not with us. Then he started the genetic engineering through a man called Abram. At the time he and his people were just another race on the planet. Understand, it could have been an oriental, it could have been any race at that time. But it was Abram who was best suited for the Fathers work. Then began the teaching of Abram by the Father. When Joseph was taken into Slavery into Egypt the genetic engineering began. Look at it. A man was even struck dead by the Father for letting his issue go onto the ground. Just look! With this change in our bodies our food was changed through the Levitical laws after Moses. Then the real intelligence of mankind began and our bodies became such that could support strong spirit. Such as the Christ whoes body and spirit were complete. In fact, the body could not hold strong spirit until the resurrection of Christ and he left us with the Paracliese. We could finally hold strong spirit. God Bless us in our search for Truth.
Ezekiel baking bread using a fire made of animal dung is nothing unusual. Dried animal dung has been used for fires ever since humans discovered how to use fire. The pioneers moving west over the Great Plains in the 19th Century, traveled in Conestoga wagons. Under the wagon was fastened a heavy piece of cloth and as the wagon train traveled, the women and children would collect dried “buffalo chips” and place them in the cloth. When stopped and fires were made, the buffalo chips were used as fuel.
Actually, the Genesis account does not teach that these trees had any peculiar or supernatural powers of their own. Rather, they were actual trees that Jehovah invested with symbolic meaning.
What, then, did the two trees symbolize? Many complex theories have been put forward. The genuine answer, while simple, is quite profound. The tree of the knowledge of good and bad represented a privilege that is God’s province alone—the right to determine what is good and what is bad. (Jeremiah 10:23) No wonder it was a crime to steal from that tree! The tree of life, on the other hand, represented a gift that only God can bestow—everlasting life.—Romans 6:23.
The web link provided to a pdf in my previous comment (#2) is no longer available for free. “Chemically-Induced Visions in the Fourth Book of Ezra in Light of Comparative Persian Material” explains how Jewish visionary accounts in such works as the Fourth Book of Ezra (also referred to as 2 Esdras, 9:23-29, 12:51, 14:38-48) and in “Martyrdom of Isaiah” (2:7-11) describe a mind-altering experience as a result of ingesting certain psychotropic plants that were patterned after Zoroastrian writings and were probably written after 70 C.E. This tradition, however, can be traced back to the period of Greek influence following the conquest by Alexander the Great when it became a virtue to abstain from meat and wine and subsist on vegetables (Daniel 1:8-15). Vincente Dobroruka writes:
“In the first passage, 4Ezra 9:23-29, we have a dialogue between God and Ezra where the seer is still perplexed about the fate of the wicked in relation to the righteous. For God to explain in further detail to Ezra why so many will perish while He is only concerned about hte fate of the just. He orders Ezra to go to a field without any human construction and not fast, but instead eat only the flowers of the field and abstain from meat or wine (4Ezra 9:23-25).
‘But if you let seven days more pass – do not fast during them, however; but go into a field of flowers where no house has been built, and eat only the flowers of the field, and taste no meat and drink no wine, but eat only flowers, and pray to then Most High continually – then I will come and talk with you.’
Here again the theme of vegetarianism is present (maybe as a reminder of the pre-diluvian diet that man enjoyed once, thus closer to Edenic times), but hte reference to the eating of flowers alone is striking and even absent from some versions of the text…” http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/ancient-cultures/ancient-israel/cache-of-jewelry-coins-of-alexander-the-great-israel/
It’s not food made upon human excrement in Ezekiel. It is food cooked on a FIRE that is MADE from excrement. Please, if you are going to quote the Bible get it correct. There’s a huge difference in the two.
In response to Judith’s inquiry about the trial by ordeal of a woman suspected of adultery known as Sotah (Numbers 5:11-31), it is based on a word that means “turn aside,” and in this case refers to iniquity. In a book of mysticism known as the Bahir, there is a play on words between ‘satah’ (iniquity) with the letter teth (soft ‘t’) and ‘satah’ (conceal) with the letter tau (hard ‘t’) that is found in Genesis 38:15, where Judah mistakens Tamar for a prostitute after she conceals (satah) her face.
“The word Satan means ‘turning aside,’ since he turns all the world aside to the balance of guilt. How is this indicated? It is written (Genesis 38:16), ‘And he turned aside to her,’ and the Targum renders this VaSata, [Satah being the root of Satan[. It is likewise written (Proverbs 4:15), ‘Turn aside (S’teh) from it and pass on'” (The Bahir, by Aryeh Kaplan, p.62).
In other words, get on with your studies and don’t emulate the self-appointed “vice police” who are always on the lookout for women who wear make-up so they might defile themselves by physically touching the women in order to wipe off the lipstick, thereby making themselves a laughing-stock like Judah who only proved that women are more worthy to hold the very office that the men themselves have prostituted.
The author has the benefit of knowing the Jewish traditions to be able to compose such an article. No offence intended but I think it’s ironic how this scholar’s trajectary began at YU along the upscale upper east side of Manhattan, where outsides its gates the socially accepted alchohol culture dominates portrayed in the log-running televsion sit-com “Cheers” (where everybody knows your name, and the episodes are all the same). Then on to NYU in the leafy heart of The Village where it is not so upscale so as to clinicly sterilize any reference to the “cattle herb” that Jews living in exile in Babylonia would have been familiar with as farm laborers and were in a class designated in an old Sumerian tablet as the “knocked-down kicked-under people.”
In “Food of the Gods; The Search For the Original Tree of Knowledge” by Terence McKenna, the origin of this mysterious plant that gives knowledge of the divine realm began with psychoactive mushroom cults form Africa and Europe as well as the milky-white juice Soma (probably ground up cannabis and ephedrin) of the Indo-Europeans from Central Asia, and was eventually replaced with, not suprisingly, alchohol (where everybody knows your name, and all your secrets just the same). On page 141 a quote is given from”Water and Wine” by E.S. Drower:
“Fruits rich in seed, such as pomegranates and figs, appear from the earliest times as symbols of fecundity. The vine and its juice has a long history of religious significance. Deified, like the Zoroastrian haoma and Vedic soma, its powers of exhilaration and intoxication were thought to be manistefations of divine possession. In the group of sacraments or ‘mysteries’ that we shall examine,…the vine symbolizes especially the fruitfullness of woman, and its juice, mostly unfermented, is drunk ceremonially in order to promote the ferility of the womb.”
Perhaps the tradition of Soma use was preserved in Genesis 49:12; “His eyes are darker than wine, his teeth are whiter than milk.”
@Benny. I can’t vouch for a YU education but to be fair what point has the author missed? His statement is basically a direct quote of Gen 3:22 which is represented as God’s own declaration.
Peace.
Dairy Products and Beverages. Also important as food were milk and milk products, using milk of cows, goats, or sheep. (1Sa 17:18) Milk was normally kept in skin bottles. (Jg 4:19) It would sour quickly. The Hebrew word chem·ʼah′, translated “butter,” can also mean “curdled milk.” Cheese was also a well-known item. In fact, the Tyropoeon (Cheesemakers’) Valley ran along the W side of the very early city of Jerusalem.—Jg 5:25; 2Sa 17:29; Job 10:10; see CHEESE. http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200001541#h=16:0-16:861
Bread of life:
When God created Adam, he proceeded to “blow into his nostrils the breath [form of nesha·mah′] of life, and the man came to be a living soul.” (Ge 2:7) This “breath of life” not only filled the lungs with air but also imparted to the body the life-force that is sustained by breathing. The breath being drawn into the body through the nostrils is essential to life; it sustains the life-force. At the Flood, “everything in which the breath of the force of life was active in its nostrils, namely, all that were on the dry ground, died.”—Ge 7:22. http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200270933
Hidden manna:
Christ also used the jar of manna symbolically when he assured his spirit-anointed followers that those who prove to be conquerors would receive “the hidden manna,” an imperishable food supply or that which results from such a supply, in their case, immortality and incorruptibility in heaven.—Re 2:17; 1Co 15:53.http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200273643
For me, the strangest but most wonderful food is the Bread of life (John 6:48, 51), if any man eats from this bread, he shall live forever.
Another strange food is the hidden manna (Rev 2:17)
The creation story in the second chapter of Genesis is older than the account given in the first chapter and it has many parallels in Sumerian mythology. One such myth is called “Cattle and Grain” and is described in Samuel Kramer’s “Sumerian Mythology,” p.53:
“The myth involving Lahar, the cattle god, and his sister Anshan, the grain goddess, represents another variation of the Cain-Abel motif in Near East mythology. Lahar and Anshan, according to our myth, were created in the creation chamber of the gods in order that the Anunnaki, the children and followers of the heaven god An, might have food to eat and clothes to wear. But the Anunnaki were unable to make effective use of the products of these deities; it was to remedy this situation that man was created.”
Here we can compare the situation of the heavenly gods being dependent on the products of earth, as “in the day Yahweh Elohim made the earth and heaven (Genesis 2:4). Note that the earth is mentioned before heaven . Kramer provides an introduction to this myth (p.72):
“After on the mountain of heaven and earth,
An (the heaven god) had caused the Anunnaki (his followers) to be born,
Because the name Anshan (the grain-goddess) had not been born, had not been fashioned,
Because Uttu (a name associated with a spider web, alluding to the spinning of fabric) had not been fashioned,
Because to Uttu no temenos (shrine) had been set up,
There was no ewe, no lamb was dropped,
There was no goat, no kid was dropped…”
Compare this with “there was no shrub (syach) of the field, there was no herb (asub) of the field” (Genesis 2:5), where the shrub is human food (grain) and the herb is animal feed.
The correct term for’herb’ in Genesis 2:5 is ‘asub’ and in Daniel 4:29-30 it is ‘asuba’ and in Dueteronomy 11:15, it is Yahweh, not Sin, who “wiil provide herbage in the fields for your cattle – and thus you shall eat your fill”
In response to Alex it is the “cattle herb” in Daniel 4:30. About 1000 B.C.E in Judah that is the herb (asa) that the animals eat follows the shrub (shyach) in Genesis 2:5, which is the plant that is modified for human consumption such as wheat. After the Jews returned to their homeland in the 5th century B.C.E., they brought with them a version of creation based on soma-induced visions of the prophet Zoroarster and being an agrarian society (settled), the Jews added their own categories of plants beginning with the amoeba-sprout then grass then herb and is therefore not a fruit-bearing tree (Genesis 1:11).
Perhaps this why the Akkadian moon god Sin was worhiped all over the Arabian and Sinai deserts:
“Sin was also held to be wise and was believed to measure time with his waxing and waning. Moreover, by raising the marsh waters around the city of Ur, where his temple stood, he ensured the well-being of cattle by enabling them to ejoy an abundant supply of food” (“The Ultimate Encyclopedia of Mythology” by Arthur Cotterell & Rachel Storm, p. 319).
“There is a place in Arabia more or less opposite the city of Buto, where I went to try to get information about the flying snakes. On my arrival I saw their skeletons in incalculable numbers; they were piled in heaps, some of which were big, others smaller, others smaller still, and there were many piles of them. The place where these bones lie is a narrow mountain pass leading to a broad plain which joins on to the plain of Egypt, and it is said that when the winged snakes fly to Egypt from Arabia in spring, the ibises meet them at the entrance to the pass and do not let them get through, but kill them. According to the Arabians, the service is the reason for the great reference with which the Ibis is regarded in Egypt” (Herodotus, “The Histories” Book Two para. 75).
Fortunately Benny, there are people who are not scholars and thus have no reputation to uphold and who can interpret the meaning of the tree of knowlege without fearing they could let everyone down by deviating ever so slightly from tradition. The story of Nebuchadnezer eating grass like cattle (Daniel 4:30) refers to the last king of the Babylonian empire, Nabonidus, who some scholars beleive was an archaeologist who, having possibly discovered an ancient tradition regarding the moon god Sin, embarked on a mission to restore the primacy of this ancient Arabian deity originally associated with nomadic cattle herders (there was always this connection between the moon and plant growth). As for the reference to 2 Esdras 9:26, this refers to the ingestion of certain plants immediately prior to receiving a vision (in this instance, that of a woman who is the personification of Zion):
“So I went, as he directed me, into the field which is called Ardat; and there I sat among the flowers and ate of the plants of the field, and the nourshment they afforded satisfied me.”
There is an interesting pdf that Yeshiva University students can download that connects these scriptural references to psychotropic plants: http://www.pej-unb.org/downloads/art_4ezra.pdf
Cow chips, camel chips, dried horse apples and so on. It leaves no taste if it is dried, no smoke, either. Sheep, burro, and goat. Do not never ever use it from predators, no matter how well dried and seared in the sun. That contains a very nasty fungus we call witch powder, AKA to archaeologists, King Tut’s revenge. Walk in beauty.
you can find canned manna in jordan it taste good !
I would ask: If G-D is not the author of confusion ; why is he attributed to so much controversy and debate on literal vs. symbolism in Scripture? How do we differentiate ?
I would comment : ONE FOOD WE ARE OFTEN FORCED TO EAT AS BIBLICAL STUDENTS IS THE ARROGANT CRUMBS BENEATH THE CRITIC’S POSTED COMMENTS. wow. Some morsels are hard to digest lol
Donna . ( wonderful work on your Blog!!!! I love your writings!)
Thanks David for not dismissing manna as gum resin. I don’t think the Israelites would have said “What is it?” if it was simply tree sap. And it would have taken a lot of tree sap to feed a nation for 40 years. A miracle is a miracle.
Hi all. Just here to throw a wrench. I love and respect the wonderful education and discussion. Paul, all the food references are being mixed up. Some are literal and some metaphoric. As far as the trees in the Garden…..it’s too late, we bit the big one. Let the games begin. We know that in our early History mans bodies were different than ours now. When you go back to the beginning of man our air on this planet was different also. In the beginning our bodies were rugged to survive terra firma. We truly ingested a more rugged diet. Our teeth and bones say so. The problem is that man identified with apes instead of understanding the levity of our enviorment when we were first created. We had the brains however we assume that because their bodies were rugged that they were brainless and the Father was not with us. Then he started the genetic engineering through a man called Abram. At the time he and his people were just another race on the planet. Understand, it could have been an oriental, it could have been any race at that time. But it was Abram who was best suited for the Fathers work. Then began the teaching of Abram by the Father. When Joseph was taken into Slavery into Egypt the genetic engineering began. Look at it. A man was even struck dead by the Father for letting his issue go onto the ground. Just look! With this change in our bodies our food was changed through the Levitical laws after Moses. Then the real intelligence of mankind began and our bodies became such that could support strong spirit. Such as the Christ whoes body and spirit were complete. In fact, the body could not hold strong spirit until the resurrection of Christ and he left us with the Paracliese. We could finally hold strong spirit. God Bless us in our search for Truth.
Ezekiel baking bread using a fire made of animal dung is nothing unusual. Dried animal dung has been used for fires ever since humans discovered how to use fire. The pioneers moving west over the Great Plains in the 19th Century, traveled in Conestoga wagons. Under the wagon was fastened a heavy piece of cloth and as the wagon train traveled, the women and children would collect dried “buffalo chips” and place them in the cloth. When stopped and fires were made, the buffalo chips were used as fuel.
Actually, the Genesis account does not teach that these trees had any peculiar or supernatural powers of their own. Rather, they were actual trees that Jehovah invested with symbolic meaning.
See http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/2011003#h=18:1-20:393
What, then, did the two trees symbolize? Many complex theories have been put forward. The genuine answer, while simple, is quite profound. The tree of the knowledge of good and bad represented a privilege that is God’s province alone—the right to determine what is good and what is bad. (Jeremiah 10:23) No wonder it was a crime to steal from that tree! The tree of life, on the other hand, represented a gift that only God can bestow—everlasting life.—Romans 6:23.
The web link provided to a pdf in my previous comment (#2) is no longer available for free. “Chemically-Induced Visions in the Fourth Book of Ezra in Light of Comparative Persian Material” explains how Jewish visionary accounts in such works as the Fourth Book of Ezra (also referred to as 2 Esdras, 9:23-29, 12:51, 14:38-48) and in “Martyrdom of Isaiah” (2:7-11) describe a mind-altering experience as a result of ingesting certain psychotropic plants that were patterned after Zoroastrian writings and were probably written after 70 C.E. This tradition, however, can be traced back to the period of Greek influence following the conquest by Alexander the Great when it became a virtue to abstain from meat and wine and subsist on vegetables (Daniel 1:8-15). Vincente Dobroruka writes:
“In the first passage, 4Ezra 9:23-29, we have a dialogue between God and Ezra where the seer is still perplexed about the fate of the wicked in relation to the righteous. For God to explain in further detail to Ezra why so many will perish while He is only concerned about hte fate of the just. He orders Ezra to go to a field without any human construction and not fast, but instead eat only the flowers of the field and abstain from meat or wine (4Ezra 9:23-25).
‘But if you let seven days more pass – do not fast during them, however; but go into a field of flowers where no house has been built, and eat only the flowers of the field, and taste no meat and drink no wine, but eat only flowers, and pray to then Most High continually – then I will come and talk with you.’
Here again the theme of vegetarianism is present (maybe as a reminder of the pre-diluvian diet that man enjoyed once, thus closer to Edenic times), but hte reference to the eating of flowers alone is striking and even absent from some versions of the text…”
http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/ancient-cultures/ancient-israel/cache-of-jewelry-coins-of-alexander-the-great-israel/
Nice, except the part about the two trees in the garden of Eden. Which in fact are, ofcourse, Jesus and Lucifer.
It’s not food made upon human excrement in Ezekiel. It is food cooked on a FIRE that is MADE from excrement. Please, if you are going to quote the Bible get it correct. There’s a huge difference in the two.
In response to Judith’s inquiry about the trial by ordeal of a woman suspected of adultery known as Sotah (Numbers 5:11-31), it is based on a word that means “turn aside,” and in this case refers to iniquity. In a book of mysticism known as the Bahir, there is a play on words between ‘satah’ (iniquity) with the letter teth (soft ‘t’) and ‘satah’ (conceal) with the letter tau (hard ‘t’) that is found in Genesis 38:15, where Judah mistakens Tamar for a prostitute after she conceals (satah) her face.
“The word Satan means ‘turning aside,’ since he turns all the world aside to the balance of guilt. How is this indicated? It is written (Genesis 38:16), ‘And he turned aside to her,’ and the Targum renders this VaSata, [Satah being the root of Satan[. It is likewise written (Proverbs 4:15), ‘Turn aside (S’teh) from it and pass on'” (The Bahir, by Aryeh Kaplan, p.62).
In other words, get on with your studies and don’t emulate the self-appointed “vice police” who are always on the lookout for women who wear make-up so they might defile themselves by physically touching the women in order to wipe off the lipstick, thereby making themselves a laughing-stock like Judah who only proved that women are more worthy to hold the very office that the men themselves have prostituted.
The author has the benefit of knowing the Jewish traditions to be able to compose such an article. No offence intended but I think it’s ironic how this scholar’s trajectary began at YU along the upscale upper east side of Manhattan, where outsides its gates the socially accepted alchohol culture dominates portrayed in the log-running televsion sit-com “Cheers” (where everybody knows your name, and the episodes are all the same). Then on to NYU in the leafy heart of The Village where it is not so upscale so as to clinicly sterilize any reference to the “cattle herb” that Jews living in exile in Babylonia would have been familiar with as farm laborers and were in a class designated in an old Sumerian tablet as the “knocked-down kicked-under people.”
In “Food of the Gods; The Search For the Original Tree of Knowledge” by Terence McKenna, the origin of this mysterious plant that gives knowledge of the divine realm began with psychoactive mushroom cults form Africa and Europe as well as the milky-white juice Soma (probably ground up cannabis and ephedrin) of the Indo-Europeans from Central Asia, and was eventually replaced with, not suprisingly, alchohol (where everybody knows your name, and all your secrets just the same). On page 141 a quote is given from”Water and Wine” by E.S. Drower:
“Fruits rich in seed, such as pomegranates and figs, appear from the earliest times as symbols of fecundity. The vine and its juice has a long history of religious significance. Deified, like the Zoroastrian haoma and Vedic soma, its powers of exhilaration and intoxication were thought to be manistefations of divine possession. In the group of sacraments or ‘mysteries’ that we shall examine,…the vine symbolizes especially the fruitfullness of woman, and its juice, mostly unfermented, is drunk ceremonially in order to promote the ferility of the womb.”
Perhaps the tradition of Soma use was preserved in Genesis 49:12; “His eyes are darker than wine, his teeth are whiter than milk.”
What about the Sotah ritual drink in Numbers?
David, your article help me much to learn Bible deeper. Jesus bless you. Salute from Indonesia.
Johanes Saragih
@Benny. I can’t vouch for a YU education but to be fair what point has the author missed? His statement is basically a direct quote of Gen 3:22 which is represented as God’s own declaration.
Peace.
Dairy Products and Beverages. Also important as food were milk and milk products, using milk of cows, goats, or sheep. (1Sa 17:18) Milk was normally kept in skin bottles. (Jg 4:19) It would sour quickly. The Hebrew word chem·ʼah′, translated “butter,” can also mean “curdled milk.” Cheese was also a well-known item. In fact, the Tyropoeon (Cheesemakers’) Valley ran along the W side of the very early city of Jerusalem.—Jg 5:25; 2Sa 17:29; Job 10:10; see CHEESE.
http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200001541#h=16:0-16:861
Bread of life:
When God created Adam, he proceeded to “blow into his nostrils the breath [form of nesha·mah′] of life, and the man came to be a living soul.” (Ge 2:7) This “breath of life” not only filled the lungs with air but also imparted to the body the life-force that is sustained by breathing. The breath being drawn into the body through the nostrils is essential to life; it sustains the life-force. At the Flood, “everything in which the breath of the force of life was active in its nostrils, namely, all that were on the dry ground, died.”—Ge 7:22.
http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200270933
Hidden manna:
Christ also used the jar of manna symbolically when he assured his spirit-anointed followers that those who prove to be conquerors would receive “the hidden manna,” an imperishable food supply or that which results from such a supply, in their case, immortality and incorruptibility in heaven.—Re 2:17; 1Co 15:53.http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200273643
For me, the strangest but most wonderful food is the Bread of life (John 6:48, 51), if any man eats from this bread, he shall live forever.
Another strange food is the hidden manna (Rev 2:17)
The creation story in the second chapter of Genesis is older than the account given in the first chapter and it has many parallels in Sumerian mythology. One such myth is called “Cattle and Grain” and is described in Samuel Kramer’s “Sumerian Mythology,” p.53:
“The myth involving Lahar, the cattle god, and his sister Anshan, the grain goddess, represents another variation of the Cain-Abel motif in Near East mythology. Lahar and Anshan, according to our myth, were created in the creation chamber of the gods in order that the Anunnaki, the children and followers of the heaven god An, might have food to eat and clothes to wear. But the Anunnaki were unable to make effective use of the products of these deities; it was to remedy this situation that man was created.”
Here we can compare the situation of the heavenly gods being dependent on the products of earth, as “in the day Yahweh Elohim made the earth and heaven (Genesis 2:4). Note that the earth is mentioned before heaven . Kramer provides an introduction to this myth (p.72):
“After on the mountain of heaven and earth,
An (the heaven god) had caused the Anunnaki (his followers) to be born,
Because the name Anshan (the grain-goddess) had not been born, had not been fashioned,
Because Uttu (a name associated with a spider web, alluding to the spinning of fabric) had not been fashioned,
Because to Uttu no temenos (shrine) had been set up,
There was no ewe, no lamb was dropped,
There was no goat, no kid was dropped…”
Compare this with “there was no shrub (syach) of the field, there was no herb (asub) of the field” (Genesis 2:5), where the shrub is human food (grain) and the herb is animal feed.
The correct term for’herb’ in Genesis 2:5 is ‘asub’ and in Daniel 4:29-30 it is ‘asuba’ and in Dueteronomy 11:15, it is Yahweh, not Sin, who “wiil provide herbage in the fields for your cattle – and thus you shall eat your fill”
In response to Alex it is the “cattle herb” in Daniel 4:30. About 1000 B.C.E in Judah that is the herb (asa) that the animals eat follows the shrub (shyach) in Genesis 2:5, which is the plant that is modified for human consumption such as wheat. After the Jews returned to their homeland in the 5th century B.C.E., they brought with them a version of creation based on soma-induced visions of the prophet Zoroarster and being an agrarian society (settled), the Jews added their own categories of plants beginning with the amoeba-sprout then grass then herb and is therefore not a fruit-bearing tree (Genesis 1:11).
Perhaps this why the Akkadian moon god Sin was worhiped all over the Arabian and Sinai deserts:
“Sin was also held to be wise and was believed to measure time with his waxing and waning. Moreover, by raising the marsh waters around the city of Ur, where his temple stood, he ensured the well-being of cattle by enabling them to ejoy an abundant supply of food” (“The Ultimate Encyclopedia of Mythology” by Arthur Cotterell & Rachel Storm, p. 319).
“There is a place in Arabia more or less opposite the city of Buto, where I went to try to get information about the flying snakes. On my arrival I saw their skeletons in incalculable numbers; they were piled in heaps, some of which were big, others smaller, others smaller still, and there were many piles of them. The place where these bones lie is a narrow mountain pass leading to a broad plain which joins on to the plain of Egypt, and it is said that when the winged snakes fly to Egypt from Arabia in spring, the ibises meet them at the entrance to the pass and do not let them get through, but kill them. According to the Arabians, the service is the reason for the great reference with which the Ibis is regarded in Egypt” (Herodotus, “The Histories” Book Two para. 75).
and the times of famine when people ate NOTHING? wonder how that tasted.
The strangest food, in my humble opinion, would have to have been the pterodactyl or stegosaurus the Canaanites were forced to feast upon.
Fortunately Benny, there are people who are not scholars and thus have no reputation to uphold and who can interpret the meaning of the tree of knowlege without fearing they could let everyone down by deviating ever so slightly from tradition. The story of Nebuchadnezer eating grass like cattle (Daniel 4:30) refers to the last king of the Babylonian empire, Nabonidus, who some scholars beleive was an archaeologist who, having possibly discovered an ancient tradition regarding the moon god Sin, embarked on a mission to restore the primacy of this ancient Arabian deity originally associated with nomadic cattle herders (there was always this connection between the moon and plant growth). As for the reference to 2 Esdras 9:26, this refers to the ingestion of certain plants immediately prior to receiving a vision (in this instance, that of a woman who is the personification of Zion):
“So I went, as he directed me, into the field which is called Ardat; and there I sat among the flowers and ate of the plants of the field, and the nourshment they afforded satisfied me.”
There is an interesting pdf that Yeshiva University students can download that connects these scriptural references to psychotropic plants:
http://www.pej-unb.org/downloads/art_4ezra.pdf
Amazing what a YU education can do for some… “The tree of knowledge bestowed a divine knowledge of good and bad, making one like the gods.”
I think you might have missed the point…