Understanding the Jewish Menorah

Does this ancient menorah graffito show the Temple menorah?

Understanding the Jewish Menorah

Does this recently excavated ancient menorah graffito show us what the Temple menorah looked like?

The Jewish menorah—especially the Temple menorah, a seven-branched candelabra that stood in the Temple—is the most enduring and iconic Jewish symbol. But what did the Temple menorah actually look like?

In early August 2011, the Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) issued a press release announcing the discovery of “an engraving of the Temple menorah on a stone object” in a 2,000-year-old drainage channel near the City of David, which is being excavated by Professor Ronny Reich and Eli Shukron. (An unusually well preserved iron sword in its leather scabbard, which presumably belonged to a Roman soldier, was also found there.) The IAA release went on to say that “a passerby who saw the [Temple] menorah with his own eyes … incised his impressions on a stone.” The excavators were quoted as saying that this graffito “clarifies [that] the base of the original [ancient] menorah … was apparently tripod shaped.”

But does it?

Depictions of the Jewish menorah with a tripod, or three-legged, base were indeed quite popular in late antique Judaism (fourth–sixth centuries C.E.). This can be seen clearly on the mosaic floors of several synagogues (Hammath Tiberias, Beth-Shean, Beth Alpha and Nirim), not to mention inscribed plaques, oil lamps and even a tiny gold ring from the fifth century.
 


 
Our free eBook Ten Top Biblical Archaeology Discoveries brings together the exciting worlds of archaeology and the Bible! Learn the fascinating insights gained from artifacts and ruins, like the Pool of Siloam in Jerusalem, where the Gospel of John says Jesus miraculously restored the sight of the blind man, and the Tel Dan inscription—the first historical evidence of King David outside the Bible.
 

 
Although there is thus later artistic support for a tripod-based Jewish menorah, the evidence from the late Second Temple period, when the ancient menorah was still standing in the Temple, is rather different. The handful of contemporaneous depictions we have seem to show the Jewish menorah with a solid, usually triangular base. These include the fragmentary ancient menorah graffito discovered by the late Israeli archaeologist Nahman Avigad in his excavation of the Jewish Quarter in Jerusalem, multiple coins of the last Hasmonean king Mattathias Antigonus (40–37 B.C.E.) and the decorated stone table recently discovered at Magdala. (The Temple menorah pictured on the Arch of Titus in Rome has an unusual octagonal tiered base that is usually rejected as unrealistic.) Therefore this recently discovered crude drawing of a Jewish menorah hardly settles the question of what the Temple menorah’s base looked like.

Another glaring problem is that this ancient menorah has only five branches. The Temple menorah had seven branches, as did the ancient menorah in the desert Tabernacle described in Exodus 25:31–40. Although the rabbis prohibited making seven-branched menorot like the one in the Temple, some Second Temple Jewish menorah depictions (including those referred to above) do contain seven branches. So was this ancient menorah with five branches meant to represent some other Jewish menorah? Or was the artist simply in a hurry or confused? And would it have been possible for a Yohanan Q. Public to come in from the streets of Jerusalem, walk into the Temple and see the Jewish menorah?

The answer to that last question is: It depends on what time period we’re talking about. According to Professor Victor Hurowitz of Ben-Gurion University, the priestly laws of the Pentateuch prohibited viewing the menorah because the entire inside of the desert Tabernacle was off-limits to commoners (only priests could enter), and when moving the Tabernacle, the vessels (including the menorah) were covered. These restrictions continued in the First Temple period (1000–586 B.C.E.), Hurowitz explained.

But things may have changed in the Second Temple period (538 B.C.E.–70 C.E.). Hebrew University professor Israel Knohl contends that the Mishnah and the Temple Scroll indicate that in the late Second Temple period the usual purity laws related to Temple rituals were loosened somewhat during the three major pilgrimage festivals of Sukkoth, Pesach and Shavuot. To encourage popular participation in the Temple rites and the festival service, the ritual purity laws that normally constrained common Israelites to the outer Temple courts were relaxed: In “a two-way movement,” ordinary Israelites were permitted to enter the inner courts, and the sanctified ritual objects, including the menorah, were moved from the Temple to the inner courts.

It is therefore possible that the artist of this recently discovered graffito could have gotten close enough during a pilgrim festival to see the menorah brought out by the priests and displayed before all the people, but the rough drawing he etched into the stone is far from giving us a clear view of what the Temple menorah looked like.

 


 

Pictured below are a number of important menorah depictions from antiquity.

Hover cursor over image to read caption.



Originally published October 2011, updated June 2014.
 


 

Based on “Strata: Is This What the Temple Menorah Looked Like?” Biblical Archaeology Review, November/December 2011.

Posted in Image Galleries, Temple at Jerusalem.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

Add Your Comments

12 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Carl says

    Excuse me, “…the base of the original Menorah…”? There’s more than one Temple Menorah in Israel’s past ! ?

  2. Ramon A says

    My take is that the Menorah depictions are flat for a lack of perspective knowledge in art. THe original should be a three dimensional artifact consisting of a central flame and two concentric “rings” of flames. That would render the menorah to be a powerful seven torch unified flame which had to be depicted in drawing as seven flattened independent tubes.

  3. graca says

    If you can read the paper “A Jewish Intaglio from Roman Ammaia, Lusitania” (by me and Shua Amorai-Stark, 2005, Jerusalem) you will see the depiction of a Menorah in a Roman item from present day Portugal.

    Graça Cravinho

  4. Joel says

    That rollover caption thing is rubbish.

  5. Mark L. says

    Joel is correct. The rollover caption design is like a duck shoot at the county fair. While we try to read a caption, the rollover design has moved on three pictures down the row. Very frustrating. The design needs to be rethought. The subject, however, is compelling. Thanks.

  6. Diana says

    Maybe it is not a Menorah? Maybe it is just a simple candle stand? Not everything is so complicated…

  7. Sue says

    I am confused. My Jewish friend says that they light eight candles in the menorah at chanukah, one being in front of the others. I have seen fire, nine and seven candle holding menorah but not eight. Sue

  8. Anna says

    love yall

  9. Gloria says

    Ditto Mark L’s comments.

  10. Lois says

    Sue,
    The eight candle menorah has to do with Hanakuh tradition regarding the oil lasting for eight days in the time of the Maccabees revolt.; It is a different menorah than the original described in the Bible. I am always surprised when I go into stores selling these and they don’t even know about the seven lamp menorah.
    Lois

Continuing the Discussion

  1. Elias-Bachrach family blog » Blog Archive » The shape of the menorah linked to this post on January 31, 2012

    [...] ancient menorah depicted on coins, mosaics, pottery, and even ancient graffiti. While there is some debate about what the base of the menorah looked like, all the graphical representations show the menorah with curved arms. The [...]

  2. Breaking Tradition (to Be in a Native American language) | My Blog linked to this post on December 3, 2012

    [...] America and other continents.  The latter book additionally contained not only a picture of a Menorah [...]


Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.


Enter Your Log In Credentials

Change Password

×