Who Really Invented the Alphabet—Illiterate Miners or Educated Sophisticates?

Introduction

<< Back to Scholar's Study

In a landmark article in the March/April 2010 issue of BAR, Orly Goldwasser, professor of Egyptology at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, explained how the very first alphabet, from which all other alphabets developed, was invented by illiterate Canaanite miners in the turquoise mines of Serabit el-Khadem in the Sinai peninsula. Inspired by Egyptian pictorial hieroglyphs and a desire to articulate their own thoughts in writing, these Canaanites created 22 alphabetic acrophonetic signs scratched into the rock that could express their entire language.
 


 
Read “How the Alphabet Was Born from Hieroglyphs” by Orly Goldwasser as it appeared in the March/April 2010 issue of BAR.
 

 
But Goldwasser did not convince everyone. Anson Rainey, emeritus professor of Ancient Near Eastern Cultures and Semitic Languages at Tel Aviv University, promptly responded to the article with his doubts that this watershed moment in human culture had been brought about by illiterate miners. In his letter Rainey argues that the alphabet was surely created by “highly sophisticated Northwest Semites”; who inscribed countless papyrus sheets that have not survived.

Join us below to read Rainey’s critiques and Goldwasser’s thorough rebuttals about who really invented the alphabet.

Posted in Daily Life and Practice, Inscriptions, Scholar’s Study.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

Add Your Comments

16 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. D says

    I yield to no one in my admiration for the late Dr. Rainey. But Orly Goldwasser has the better argument here.

  2. Arnie says

    I’m reluctant to enter this fray but it’s a lot easier to believe that the early Hieroglyphs evolved into the Hieratic then to Demotic, then to modern Arabic and finally to our current alphabet than some miners drawing on a wall to convey “let’s dig here”.

    Think of Occam’s Razor.

    Cheers

  3. Mervyn says

    Thge israelites were slaves of Egypt and some almost certainly worked in the mines in Soithern Sinaia. We know that Moses was told by God to tell his people to “write these words and learn them”. That means that as early as the time of Moses (1500 BCE) , the Israleites could write.

    Why jump to conclusions that the Alaph Beth was a Canaanite or Phonecian invention?

  4. Mervyn says

    Furthger, the Israelites worked as skilledand literate builders, architects, surveyors, and possibly other professional jobs needing writing. The case is strong that the Israelites were the first inventors of Aleph Beth – a giant step forward in writing.

  5. Eve says

    In my chronology, the twelfth dynasty was the Residence of the supreme pharaoh among several concurrant dynasties as depticted in the Karnak Kings List and noted by its pharaohs names written in reverse order in the Saqqara Kings List. My dates for the reign of Amenemhat III are 1827-1779 BC. According to Orly Goldwasser’s 2006 article “Canaanites Reading Hieroglyphs: Horus is Hathor? – The Invention of the Alphabet in Sinai,” Keel dated one of Amenemhat III’s unique scarabs to the 13th dynasty. The seal is unique because it has a human hieroglyph determinative in a Canaanite style called protosinaitic script found mostly near the copper and turquoise mines of Sinai. The laborers of the mines fused Egyptian hieroglyphs with some Hebrew letters, and some short-cuts of their own, and made scarab-seals for Egyptian dignitaries in the Delta and abroad. Goldwasser then determined the following:
    1) People in Syria liked their ideas and created a cuneiform version called Ugaritic.
    2) Byblos, on the Syrian coast, may have influenced these miners in the way they wrote the name Hathor, the goddess of turquoise, with a Horus bird and an angle instead of a falcon in a square.
    3) The protosinaitic script is found on a Sinai stela dated to Amenemhat III’s 23rd year, at Wadi Magharah dated to Amenemhat III’s 42nd year, and the mines of Serabit el Khadim in Amenemhat III’s 45th year.
    {This modified paragraph is from pages 395 of my book Pharaohs of the Bible. I agree with Goldwasser.}

  6. Joseph says

    The Alphabet was invented by Joseph and his brothers when they were put to work at feeding the ‘whole world’ in Egypt. It was refined from the 13th Dynasty onwards, and used by the “Canaanites” down in Sinai.

  7. George says

    The conviction that the Hebrew-Phoenician-Greek-Etruscan-Roman alphabet was derived from a far out group of miners in the Sinai desert is just plain silly.

    The concept was disseminated throughout the Mediterranean world by Cretan mariners; and the host trading ports picked and chose from the Cretan repertoire of syllabic signs – those that best fit the language of the host trading partner.

    Joesph’s post (# 6) comes closest to being correct.

  8. Alan says

    According to Wikipedia, hieratic was in existence at least as early as 1600 B.C., existed alongside Egyptian hieroglyphs, and may even have preceded Egyptian hieroglyphs – going back to the pre-dynastic period. Thus, (an early version of) it may have arrived in Egypt with the pre-dynastic migration of Semitic people into the Nile delta (c. 3000 B.C.)?

    As an abjad written from right to left (but with logographic elements), hieratic would seem to be a logical choice for the precursor to Phoenician/Proto-Hebrew, and other early (& apparently related) abjads.

    But no one seems to have looked at a possible connection between hieratic & later scripts. (Or it has been determined that they are probably not related)?

  9. Alan says

    Given the sophistication of hieratic 500 or more years before the appearance of proto-Canaanite (or whatever it is supposed to be called), and given that hieratic was an abjad (albeit with logograms), it seems to me that it is silly (culturally biased) to even talk about those scratchings in the Sinai as the “invention” of the alphabet. Certainly it cannot be claimed to be the first example of some form of an abjad, or that some Canaanite/Israelite genius (regardless of whether or not he or she was illiterate) was the first to use some symbols to represent his language phonetically.

    But the use of only 22 symbols was certainly a radical breakthrough. And no one seems to think that hieratic lead directly to that early form of Hebrew/Canaanite/Phoenician. And so, from our western perspective, we could say that, as far as can be determined by the evidence at this point, it was apparently some Israelite/Canaanite genius who living somewhere in Egypt who “invented” what we think of as “the alphabet” (c.1700 B.C.E.?)

    As for whether or not that genius was an “ancient academic” or an illiterate laborer, Goldwasser makes some good points. But I would point out that just because someone (or a race of people) may be living in poverty/slavery, that does not mean that that was always the case, or that they could not also have a long tradition of education/literacy.

  10. berkley says

    Semitic writing was no doubt developed by merchants for the sake of inventory, invoices and receipts. Part of mining is engineering which also requires precision and documentation. If early documents were portable and on papyrus or parchment, they would not have survived 3,000 years. We can only hope early clay records or scratches on oistraka or stone engravings will be dug up to provide further evidence. The ‘miners’ in question could also have been well-educated men who chose this work because it paid well. No answer can be ruled out in the absence of proof.

  11. MICHELLE says

    “Apparently” the epic-graphy and alphabetic innovation reflects periodic-evolution in “A” formal context of symbolic/images both orthographic – scripts and language/etymologies. The universal thought and continual progression appears to have begun 25,000 years ago, however the use of columnar identification in symbolic/lettering regards a mentoring community. The Egyptian/Sinatic-Phoenician-Canaanite [Judiac-Hebrew/Phoenician] identification[s]‘ of symbols and varietal meanings – - are a descriptive reality-whether remote or clandenstine in nature. What remains is “that’ discerning ideal of religious spirituality/ beliefs … A ” series” of 18- 22 letters, singularily or clustered in groups were invented about 3,000 B.C., and placed accordingly. Some how – “pristine in nature” and attributed by the ancient dwellers or nomadic travelors. Tribal ethnologies chose applicative usage in ceromonial practices/cultivational endeavors … and Cultural communicative histories.

  12. Jack says

    I tend to accept Goldwasser’s position. However since I am neither an Archaeologist or a Linguist my limited ans ONLY argument is based on motivation. Scribes would favor a complex and therefore specialized form of communication. Their status and probably standard of living would have been threatened by a simpler form of writing. The lower classes and possibly engineers would have found an efficient language beneficial..

    OFF TOPIC
    I decided to post a reply to this thread because I have a related motivational problem in regard to Empire Jews paying the Temple tax.”The first Roman attempt to halt payments of the tax was made long before the Jewish War on account of customs controls.” ref. Wikipedia Temple Tax

    It seems this was a voluntary tax. My rule of thumb is that people don’t pay a “voluntary” tax unless they get some benefit from it. I have not been able to find any discussion of this subject. As Roman hostility to the tax as well as client state status for Judea tensions would rise particularly for Empire Jews with Roman citizenship such as Paul.

    What I am looking for is a semi-popular work on the subject, since that is what I have been reading for the last 40 years. Anyone?

  13. julie says

    this helped me with my home work. Thx.

  14. julie says

    this helped me. THx.

  15. Varghese says

    What is wrong with you all? Do you all suppose that Noah could construct a ship sophisticated enough to have stayed afloat in such a turbulent atmosphere for such a long time as mentioned in the bible keeping all (probably more than) these wide variety species of animals and birds that we see around us on the earth today without having had the skills of accounting / keeping records which necessitates the ability to read and write?

Continuing the Discussion


Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.


Enter Your Log In Credentials

Change Password

×